Shearer's Bellingham Theory: Is Tuchel Sending a Message with Alexander-Arnold Omission?

Alan Shearer has floated a curious theory to explain Thomas Tuchel's continued exclusion of Trent Alexander-Arnold from the England set-up: that the Liverpool-turned-Madrid right-back might represent a problematic influence alongside Jude Bellingham.

The speculation emerged on The Rest Is Football following Tuchel's announcement of a 35-man squad for upcoming friendlies against Uruguay and Japan. While the squad contained eyebrow-raising selections including Dominic Calvert-Lewin, James Garner, and Jason Steele, Alexander-Arnold's name was conspicuously absent—marking his fourth consecutive omission.

Previously, injury and his difficult Madrid transition offered straightforward explanations. But with the former Liverpool star back in regular action at the Bernabéu since February, his continued exile takes on a different complexion. Tuchel has instead plumped for Tino Livramento and Djed Spence at right-back, while Ben White's inclusion as a replacement for Jarell Quansah represents a particularly stinging snub.

Lineker opened proceedings by questioning the wisdom of Tuchel's approach, particularly given Alexander-Arnold's proven ability to influence matches from the bench. He referenced reports—apparently originating from Marca—suggesting the player had been late for training, potentially explaining his absence from a recent Real Madrid fixture. Yet Lineker stressed that even if Alexander-Arnold isn't trusted as a starter, his exceptional delivery and passing range represent an asset too valuable to overlook in knockout football.

Shearer then ventured into murkier territory, wondering aloud whether Tuchel harbours concerns about Bellingham and Alexander-Arnold operating as a combined force within the squad dynamic. The suggestion prompted Lineker to label the theory "bizarre," though he acknowledged Tuchel might be deploying squad omissions as a disciplinary tool—having previously dropped Bellingham before now freezing out Alexander-Arnold.

Lineker concluded by stressing the impossibility of outsiders determining whether genuine friction exists between manager and players, emphasizing that Tuchel alone holds the power to shape his selections. What remains undeniable is that Alexander-Arnold's World Cup prospects have darkened considerably, and the talent being squandered raises uncomfortable echoes of past England mismanagement.